Courtney Sandora, founder of the digital marketing agency Go Social, which specializes in the spirits industry, is sounding the alarm for brands navigating the rapidly evolving landscape of online discovery. With a background in journalism and public relations, Sandora has long been fascinated by how consumers find and engage with brands. Her current focus is on the seismic shift driven by artificial intelligence, a phenomenon she terms "Answer Engine Optimization" (AEO), and its profound implications for brands aiming to capture consumer attention, particularly during crucial periods like the holiday shopping season and beyond. This article delves into Sandora’s insights and provides a deeper analysis of the challenges and opportunities presented by AEO.
Sandora’s entrepreneurial journey began over 16 years ago, driven by a desire for greater autonomy and a keen interest in emerging trends. "I’ve always been interested in when something new comes on the scene. How does that impact how people discover brands and how our brands are recommended?" she stated. This curiosity led her to the forefront of AI visibility, a space she finds particularly exhilarating. Approximately 18 months ago, she began experimenting with large language models (LLMs) like ChatGPT to analyze how brands, particularly those in the wine and whiskey sectors, were being represented. Her findings were illuminating.
"ChatGPT is citing the publication Whiskey Wash and some of these trade publications that, quite honestly, when you tell clients, ‘Oh, I got you in that,’ they’re like, ‘Meh, it’s okay.’ It’s not the Men’s Journal of the world," Sandora explained. However, she quickly recognized the underlying significance: these niche publications were being cited because AI models perceived them as authoritative sources within their respective domains. This observation was the genesis of her understanding that AI-driven search operates on a different paradigm than traditional search engine optimization (SEO).
The Looming Shadow of Invisibility: Brands Unprepared for AEO
The central tenet of Sandora’s message is stark: brands that fail to optimize for AI will face a swift descent into digital obscurity. While traditional SEO remains relevant, the methodology for achieving visibility has fundamentally shifted. "I’m not saying SEO is totally going away, but there’s a reason I never went into SEO. It’s a different side of the brain," she noted. Sandora distinguishes between the technical, keyword-driven nature of SEO and the more narrative, relevance-focused approach required for AEO.
"This new AI world is really about understanding, ‘Where are you relevant in consumers’ lives?’ ‘What are the questions they’re going to ask that you’re going to answer?’" Sandora elaborated. This shift in focus from keyword density to contextual relevance and consumer needs is critical. A recent McKinsey study underscores this transformation, revealing that only 5% to 10% of referrals on platforms like ChatGPT originate from traditional websites when users are seeking information. This statistic is particularly striking given the historical reliance on websites for online visibility.
The McKinsey report, titled "New Front Door to the Internet: Winning in the Age of AI Search," highlights that LLMs tend to draw information from a broader spectrum of sources beyond direct website links. While specific product inquiries or direct brand comparisons might still lead an AI to a brand’s website, the majority of user queries are more conversational and context-dependent. Examples like "I’m going to San Francisco. What’s a great bar downtown?" illustrate the type of broad, experiential questions that AI is increasingly tasked with answering, often drawing from curated lists, reviews, and authoritative content rather than a single brand’s promotional material.
This divergence in information retrieval means that brands must adapt their content strategies to be discoverable within these new AI-driven information ecosystems. The era of solely optimizing for search engine algorithms is giving way to an era where brands must be optimized for the engines that answer questions.
Seeding Authority: The Power of Third-Party Endorsements
A cornerstone of Sandora’s AEO strategy is the concept of "seeding the right message with third-party authorities." She emphasizes that AI models are sophisticated enough to differentiate between promotional content and objective reporting. "AI is not going to pull its response from a brand’s website; it’s smart enough not to do that," she stated. This necessitates a strategic approach to public relations, influencer marketing, and content creation that prioritizes credible third-party validation.
"Knowing how to tell a story and seeding the right message with third-party authorities like journalists and creators becomes critical," Sandora advised. While social media platforms like Instagram may not directly drive significant LLM recommendations, their influence in shaping brand perception and generating organic conversations cannot be discounted. Platforms like LinkedIn, particularly for B2B audiences, continue to hold sway. Historically, platforms like Reddit were significant sources for AI, though Sandora notes a recent decline in their influence. Even press releases, she observes, are now recognized by AI as promotional rather than objective content, diminishing their weight in AI-generated responses.
The strategic imperative, therefore, is to cultivate a robust presence in channels that AI models deem authoritative. This involves building relationships with journalists, collaborating with credible content creators, and ensuring that brand narratives are embedded within high-quality, independent publications. The goal is to create a consistent pattern of positive third-party mentions that AI can readily identify and leverage in its responses.

Understanding the Consumer Conversation: Identifying Credible Ownership
Before a brand can effectively seed its message, it must first deeply understand the consumer landscape. Sandora advocates for a consumer-centric approach, beginning with an analysis of the overall category. "The first thing we do is we look at the category as a whole. What are people asking about bourbon in the category? You have to understand that landscape," she urged.
This involves identifying the common questions and themes that consumers are exploring through AI interfaces. While not every specific query might be visible, trends and recurring topics will emerge. "You need to determine if your brand is showing up when you ask those questions," Sandora advised. If a brand is not appearing, particularly if it’s a newer entrant, the strategic question becomes: "which questions could we credibly own?"
This is where the distinction between aspirational claims and demonstrable strengths becomes crucial. "You don’t want to go out there and say, ‘I want to be the best bourbon.’ Good luck," Sandora cautioned. Instead, brands should focus on their unique attributes and identify areas where consumer interest aligns with their offerings. "But what are your strengths as a brand? And also, do people care?" she posed. An example provided was a client attempting to champion a specific cocktail that lacked consumer interest. This strategic misstep highlighted the need to align marketing efforts with genuine consumer demand, rather than forcing a narrative that lacks traction.
Once the consumer landscape and the brand’s potential areas of ownership are identified, the next phase involves meticulously crafting and disseminating stories across various touchpoints. This storytelling extends beyond traditional PR to encompass creator collaborations and even the concise product descriptions found on retailer websites. Consistency in messaging across all these platforms is paramount.
The Pattern of Recommendation: Building Trust Through Repetition
Sandora uses the example of bourbon to illustrate the power of consistent messaging and category ownership. Brands that consistently position themselves as ideal for gifting, a category frequently queried by consumers, can solidify their presence in AI’s consideration set. "It is all about patterns. The more AI sees a third party recommending you, the more likely you’ll appear in AI searches," she explained.
However, this visibility is contingent on a crucial practical element: retail availability. "But you also have to have retail availability. If people can’t purchase, that’s going to be a problem," Sandora emphasized. A brand that is highly recommended but unavailable at the point of purchase will ultimately fail to convert consumer interest into sales, undermining its overall marketing effectiveness.
The concept of AEO is not merely about digital signals; it is about building a verifiable reputation and ensuring that the consumer journey can be completed seamlessly. AI, in its current iteration, is designed to provide helpful and actionable information. A brand that consistently appears in positive recommendations, backed by tangible availability, is far more likely to be favored by these intelligent systems.
AEO: A New Frontier, But Storytelling Remains King
The advent of Answer Engine Optimization (AEO) has sparked debate and, at times, skepticism within the marketing community. Sandora recalls early discussions on platforms like Reddit where many doubted AEO’s viability as a serious competitor to established SEO practices. Even now, she encounters clients who are being advised by their SEO contacts to focus solely on traditional tactics like FAQ pages and website tweaks. While these actions are not detrimental, Sandora asserts they are insufficient to navigate the complexities of AEO.
"AEO is a different beast," she stated unequivocally. The analogy drawn to the social media revolution is particularly apt. Just as businesses that offered basic scheduling tools were quickly eclipsed by more sophisticated, integrated solutions, Sandora predicts a similar evolution in the AEO space. "I think a lot of the early movers helping people navigate LLMs will be pushed aside as tools become more sophisticated and integrated into the various platforms," she explained.
However, Sandora remains optimistic about the enduring need for human expertise in the realm of strategic communication. "But I’m banking on the idea that people are still going to need help figuring out the story they want to own and how to tell it," she concluded. The core of effective marketing, she believes, will continue to revolve around compelling narratives, authentic brand positioning, and the ability to connect with consumers on a deeper, more meaningful level. While the channels and algorithms may change, the fundamental principles of good storytelling and strategic communication remain the bedrock of brand success, even in the age of artificial intelligence. The challenge for brands now is to master these principles within the new framework of AEO, ensuring they are not just visible, but genuinely valuable to consumers seeking answers in an increasingly AI-driven world.







