S&P Global Ratings Maintains Lowest Stability Score for Tether’s USDt Amid Rising Risk in Reserve Composition

S&P Global Ratings has reaffirmed its lowest possible stability assessment for Tether’s USDt, assigning it a score of 5, indicating a "weak" ability to maintain its dollar peg. This unchanged assessment, consistent since November 2025, comes as the stablecoin’s reserves show a growing allocation towards assets deemed riskier by the ratings agency. The decision underscores a persistent tension between traditional financial risk assessment methodologies and the evolving landscape of digital asset backing, particularly for the world’s largest stablecoin.

The recent report, published on November 18, highlighted a notable increase in higher-risk holdings within USDt’s reserves. As of September 30, these assets—encompassing gold, Bitcoin (BTC), public equities, secured loans, and corporate bonds—constituted 28% of USDt in circulation, a significant rise from 24% just a year prior. S&P Global Ratings explicitly warned that "A significant drop in the value of these assets could lead to USDT being undercollateralized," raising concerns about the stablecoin’s long-term resilience and its capacity to withstand market shocks.

Tether, the issuer of USDt, has vehemently disputed S&P’s assessment, framing the critique as a fundamental misunderstanding of its operational model and reserve strategy. In a statement to Cointelegraph, Tether asserted, "The problem is S&P’s framework, not our reserves." The company provocatively referenced "The Big Short," the film depicting the 2008 financial crisis, implying that S&P’s traditional rating methodologies might be ill-equipped to evaluate innovative financial structures and could be prone to similar misjudgments that preceded past economic downturns. This rebuttal positions Tether as a disruptor whose robust, albeit unconventional, backing strategy is being unfairly scrutinized by outdated financial paradigms.

A Deeper Look into Tether’s Reserves and S&P’s Concerns

Tether’s latest attested reserve report, dated September 30 and verified by BDO, presented a picture of overall solvency, showing approximately $191.5 billion in assets against $183.5 billion in liabilities. This left a substantial surplus of roughly $7.95 billion in excess assets, which Tether frequently points to as a robust buffer against volatility. However, S&P’s concerns transcend mere numerical superiority of assets over liabilities. The agency’s focus is acutely on the composition and quality of these reserves.

For a stablecoin like USDt, designed to maintain a 1:1 peg with the U.S. dollar, the ideal reserve composition, according to traditional financial standards, typically involves highly liquid, low-risk assets such as short-term U.S. Treasury bills, cash, and cash equivalents held in regulated financial institutions. The inclusion of assets like Bitcoin, public equities, and corporate bonds, while potentially offering higher returns, introduces market volatility and credit risk that are generally considered antithetical to the stability mandate of a stablecoin. Gold, while a traditional store of value, also carries its own price fluctuations and liquidity considerations, especially in large volumes. Secured loans, depending on their underlying collateral and counterparty risk, can also present varying degrees of risk and illiquidity.

S&P noted that despite finding "further weaknesses," it could not make a downward adjustment to the rating "because our assessment cannot be lower than 5." This statement underscores the severity of their concerns, indicating that if their scale allowed, USDt’s rating might have been even lower.

Regulatory Oversight and Jurisdictional Concerns

A significant point of contention raised by S&P Global Ratings revolves around the regulatory environment in El Salvador, where Tether relocated its operational base in January 2025. This move has placed Tether under the oversight of the National Commission of Digital Assets of El Salvador (CNAD). S&P’s report scrutinized CNAD’s regulatory framework, particularly its requirement that 70% of reserves be held in assets that can be liquidated within 30 days.

While this requirement mandates a degree of liquidity, S&P considered the framework "broad." This "broadness," in the agency’s view, allows for the inclusion of a relatively wide range of assets, including the aforementioned gold, Bitcoin, and various loans, which S&P classifies as higher-risk. In contrast, regulatory bodies in jurisdictions like the United States and Europe often impose stricter qualitative criteria on stablecoin reserves, emphasizing assets with minimal credit risk and immediate liquidity, such as overnight deposits and short-term government securities. The perception is that El Salvador’s nascent regulatory framework for digital assets may not offer the same level of stringent oversight and investor protection as more established financial jurisdictions.

Furthermore, S&P highlighted the critical absence of a requirement to segregate reserve assets in El Salvador, a standard practice expected by regulators in the US and Europe. Asset segregation is a cornerstone of investor protection, ensuring that a company’s operational assets are kept entirely separate from customer or token holder funds. This segregation is crucial for insulating reserve assets from broader corporate risks, such creditor claims against the parent company, or operational losses. Without publicly available information regarding such segregation, S&P concluded that there is "no insight into how they are insulated from broader corporate risks," leaving a significant transparency gap concerning the safety of USDt’s backing.

Transparency and Audit Disclosure Remain a Concern

Tether invokes The Big Short in swipe at S&P over USDT reserve risks

Another major area of critique for S&P Global Ratings concerns Tether’s approach to audits and financial disclosures. In August 2026, KPMG confirmed it had issued an unqualified opinion on Tether’s 2025 accounts, marking what the company hailed as its first "full independent audit." An unqualified opinion, also known as a clean audit opinion, is generally considered the best outcome of an audit, indicating that the financial statements are presented fairly and accurately, in all material respects, in accordance with the applicable financial reporting framework. Tether highlighted this as proof of its financial soundness and transparency.

However, S&P’s report cast a shadow over this achievement by pointing out that the audited statements and the auditor’s full report have not been publicly published. This lack of public disclosure significantly limits S&P’s, and indeed the broader market’s, ability to independently verify the underlying information, methodologies, and specific findings that led to KPMG’s opinion. For a ratings agency that relies on granular data and transparent reporting to make its assessments, the absence of these documents represents a critical impediment to full confidence.

The ratings agency also noted that Tether’s reserve reports do not name the custodians and counterparties holding its assets. In traditional finance, knowing the custodians of significant assets is standard practice, as it allows for an assessment of counterparty risk and the financial health and regulatory standing of those institutions. The omission of this detail further contributes to S&P’s transparency concerns.

Moreover, S&P highlighted the frequency of Tether’s attestations, which remain quarterly. While attestations provide a snapshot of reserves at a specific point in time, other major stablecoins, particularly those aiming for higher levels of transparency and regulatory compliance, generally report their reserves monthly. This difference in reporting frequency means that there are longer periods between public disclosures for USDt, potentially delaying the identification of significant changes in reserve composition or value.

Chronology of Scrutiny and Resilience

The narrative of S&P’s ongoing assessment of Tether is part of a longer chronology of scrutiny that has surrounded the stablecoin issuer:

  • November 2025: S&P Global Ratings initially assigns USDt its lowest stability rating of 5 (weak), setting the precedent for its current assessment. At this time, Tether disputed the result, with CEO Paolo Ardoino famously stating on X (then Twitter), "we wear your loathing with pride," and criticizing traditional financial systems as "broken."
  • January 2025: Tether relocates its operational base to El Salvador, seeking a forward-looking regulatory environment for digital assets under the National Commission of Digital Assets (CNAD).
  • September 30, 2026: Tether releases its latest attested reserve report by BDO, showing $191.5 billion in assets against $183.5 billion in liabilities.
  • August 2026: KPMG confirms it issued an unqualified opinion on Tether’s 2025 accounts, marking a significant milestone for the company in terms of audit verification, albeit with S&P noting the full report’s non-publication.
  • November 18, 2026: S&P Global Ratings publishes its latest report, reaffirming the ‘5 (weak)’ rating, citing increased riskier assets and concerns over regulatory oversight and transparency.

Broader Implications and Market Impact

S&P Global Ratings’ persistent low score for USDt carries significant implications for the broader cryptocurrency market and for institutional adoption of stablecoins. As the largest stablecoin by market capitalization, USDt plays a crucial role in providing liquidity and facilitating trading across numerous cryptocurrency exchanges. Any perceived instability or lack of transparency in its backing can ripple through the entire digital asset ecosystem.

For institutional investors, who typically operate under strict regulatory mandates and risk management protocols, a "weak" rating from a prominent agency like S&P Global Ratings could act as a deterrent. These entities often rely on independent ratings to gauge the risk profiles of assets before allocation. The concerns raised by S&P regarding reserve composition, regulatory oversight, and audit transparency might hinder broader institutional engagement with USDt, pushing them towards stablecoins that align more closely with traditional finance’s expectations for reserve management and disclosure.

The ongoing debate also highlights the broader challenge of integrating novel financial instruments like stablecoins into established regulatory and risk assessment frameworks. Traditional ratings agencies, rooted in decades of evaluating conventional assets, are adapting their methodologies to a rapidly evolving digital landscape. Their conservative approach often clashes with the innovative and sometimes less transparent practices prevalent in the nascent crypto industry. This tension is likely to persist as regulators worldwide grapple with establishing comprehensive frameworks for stablecoins.

A Nuanced Conclusion

Despite the critical assessment, S&P Global Ratings concluded its November 18 report with a notable acknowledgement: Tether had "maintained a good history of price stability, particularly in the last 12 months." This statement introduces a degree of nuance to the otherwise stark rating. It suggests that while S&P harbors significant concerns about the underlying risk profile and transparency of USDt’s reserves, the stablecoin has, in practice, successfully maintained its peg to the dollar, even during periods of market volatility.

This dichotomy underscores the complex nature of evaluating stablecoins. On one hand, traditional financial analysis emphasizes the potential for risk inherent in asset composition and governance structures. On the other hand, market performance and actual peg stability offer a real-world indicator of resilience. The challenge for Tether and the broader stablecoin industry is to bridge this gap, either by aligning more closely with traditional transparency and reserve standards or by convincing established financial institutions that their innovative approaches offer comparable or superior stability through different means. The dialogue between Tether and S&P Global Ratings is a microcosm of the larger conversation about how traditional finance will ultimately integrate, or regulate, the future of digital assets.

Related Posts

BTCPay Server Issues Critical Emergency Update Addressing Five Nginx Remote Code Execution Vulnerabilities Amidst Heightened Cybersecurity Concerns

BTCPay Server, a prominent open-source and self-hosted Bitcoin payment processor, has issued an urgent emergency update, compelling operators to address five critical security vulnerabilities discovered in Nginx, the widely-used web…

Functional Encryption: A Novel Approach to Bitcoin Covenants Explores No-Fork Spending Restrictions, Faces Significant Cryptographic Hurdles

The intricate process of evolving Bitcoin’s core protocol is a testament to its foundational design principles, prioritizing security and decentralization above rapid change. Modifying Bitcoin’s consensus rules is far from…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You Missed

Persistent UK Inflationary Pressures Reinforce Bank of England’s Hawkish Stance and Bolster Pound Sterling

Persistent UK Inflationary Pressures Reinforce Bank of England’s Hawkish Stance and Bolster Pound Sterling

St. Louis Fed President Musalem Signals Potentially Four More Rate Hikes to Tame Stubborn Inflation by Spring 2027

St. Louis Fed President Musalem Signals Potentially Four More Rate Hikes to Tame Stubborn Inflation by Spring 2027

BTCPay Server Issues Critical Emergency Update Addressing Five Nginx Remote Code Execution Vulnerabilities Amidst Heightened Cybersecurity Concerns

BTCPay Server Issues Critical Emergency Update Addressing Five Nginx Remote Code Execution Vulnerabilities Amidst Heightened Cybersecurity Concerns

Federal Reserve Board announces approval of application by Isabella Bank Corporation

Federal Reserve Board announces approval of application by Isabella Bank Corporation

The 10 Best Business Books to Put on Your Reading List in 2027

The 10 Best Business Books to Put on Your Reading List in 2027

German Government and UniCredit Forge Key Agreement on Commerzbank Takeover

German Government and UniCredit Forge Key Agreement on Commerzbank Takeover